Innovative Panel Plating for Heterogeneous Integration
A Method to Investigate PCB Supplier Rework Processes and Best Practices
The Effects of PCB Fabrication on High-Frequency Electrical Performance
Aerosol Jet Printing of Conductive Epoxy for 3D
EOS Exposure of Components in the Soldering Process
High Thermo-Mechanical Fatigue and Drop Shock Resistant Alloys
Filling of Microvias and Through Holes by Electrolytic Copper Plating
NASA DOD Phase 2: Copper Dissolution Testing
Latest Industry News
Smartphone Shipments to Plummet 11.9% in 2020
PC market to dip 7% this year
Alternate Roads to Flexible Electronics
Huawei hid business operation in Iran after Reuters reported links to CFO
Global Distributor Group Tackles Tariff Inefficiencies
How to Set Boundaries While Working Remotely
Apple must face U.S. shareholder lawsuit over CEO's iPhone, China comments
The AI-Based Competitive Revolution

Advance Board Level Modeling Wafer Level Packages

Advance Board Level Modeling Wafer Level Packages
In this paper it is determined that the effective flexural modulus depends on the stackup and it often does not correlate with the effective tensile modulus.
Analysis Lab


Authored By:

Tiao Zhou, Ph.D.
Southern Methodist University
Dallas, TX, USA

Zhenxue Han, Ph.D.
University of Texas at Arlington
Arlington, TX, USA

Tingge Xu, and Hongbing Lu, Ph.D.
University of Texas at Dallas
Dallas, TX, USA

Kenna Wang
Creekview High School
Carrollton, TX, USA


In finite element analysis (FEA) of board level temperature cycling (TC) or drop test (DT) for wafer level packaging (WLP), the printed circuit board (PCB) is often simplified as a homogeneous material. The PCB effective elastic modulus is one of the key properties required for FEA. It is obtained from tensile test, bending test, or calculation. The tensile and flexural moduli however, often have significantly different values. The FEA results thus can be inaccurate if PCB modulus is not chosen properly.

In this paper, the effects of PCB stackup, metal contents and metal trace orientations on effective tensile and flexural moduli are studied. It is determined that the effective flexural modulus depends on the stackup and it often does not correlate with the effective tensile modulus. Observations are made to assess if the PCB deformation is tension/compression dominant or bending dominant during TC and DT. Guidelines for effective elastic modulus calculation from tensile and flexural moduli are given in order to minimize the error in FEA of WLP board level TC and DT.


PCB effective elastic modulus obtained from different methods are presented. The effect of choice of elastic modulus on FEA results is investigated. The following conclusions are made:

1. The values of tensile modulus and flexural modulus are different. The flexural modulus is stackup dependent while the tensile modulus is not.

2. Smaller trance angle on routing layers results in higher effective modulus. Using Cu content alone and ignoring trace routing detail overestimates the effective modulus.

3. When simplifying the PCB as a homogeneous material, using tensile or flexural modulus alone as the effective elastic modulus in both TC and DT FEA results in error. It is recommended that:

a. Use the greater of the tensile and flexural moduli as the effective modulus for TC

b. Use the flexural modulus as the effective modulus for DT

Initially Published in the SMTA Proceedings


Interesting observation backed with substantial data. Thanks for sharing.
Pankaj Shrotre, Sierra Circuits

Submit A Comment

Comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name

Your Company
Your E-mail

Your Country
Your Comments

Board Talk
How Effective Is Nano Coating On Stencils?
What Causes Board Delamination?
01005 Component Challenges and Bugs
Sticky Residue Under Low Clearance Parts
Soldering Relays Intrusively in Lead Free Process
Printing vs. Dispensing
Maximum Board Temperature During Tin-Lead
Is There a Spacing Spec for SMD Components?
Ask the Experts
HASL vs. Immersion Gold
Very Low Temp PCBs
Looking for Long-term Component Storage Options
Baking After Cleaning Hand Placed Parts
Conformal Coating Recommendation
Burned Chip Repair
BGA Component Grounding Problem
What is the IPC Definition of Uncommonly Harsh?