Research
Combing Automated Advanced Process Control with Feedback to Revolutionize the Printed Circuit Board Assembly Process
Reliability of No-clean and Water-soluble Solder Pastes
Design and Fabrication of Ultra-Thin Flexible Substrate
Vapor Phase - Improvement Under Oxidation Free Soldering Conditions
The Perfect Copper Surface
Atmospheric Plasma Surface Engineering of Printed Circuit Boards
Stencil Aperture Design for Next Generation Ultra Fine Pitch Printing
Hybrid Conformal Coatings Used for Mitigating Whisker Growth
MORE RESEARCH
Latest Industry News
The Other Risk of Using Toxic Materials
Germany Leads the Autonomous Vehicle Regulation Race
China is kicking out more than half the world’s bitcoin miners – and a whole lot of them could be headed to Texas
The Development of Hybrid Therma-EMI Solutions for Electronics
Detect PCB Stack-up Error with Machine Learning Methods
Rocket men: Bezos, Musk and Branson scramble for space supremacy
Billionaire Alibaba founder Jack Ma spending his time on philanthropy and hobbies like painting
World Wide Web code that changed the world up for auction as NFT
MORE INDUSTRY NEWS

Maximum Board Temperature During Tin-Lead



Maximum Board Temperature During Tin-Lead
IPC discusses the maximum top-side board temperature for BGAs to be 150 degrees C during a tin-lead wave solder. How is this temperature was determined?
Board Talk
Board Talk is presented by Phil Zarrow and Jim Hall of ITM Consulting.
Process Troubleshooting, Failure Analysis, Process Audits, Process Set-up
CEM Selection/Qualification, SMT Training/Seminars, Legal Disputes
Phil Zarrow
Phil Zarrow
With over 35 years experience in PCB assembly, Phil is one of the leading experts in SMT process failure analysis. He has vast experience in SMT equipment, materials and processes.
Jim Hall
Jim Hall
A Lean Six-Sigma Master Blackbelt, Jim has a wealth of knowledge in soldering, thermal technology, equipment and process basics. He is a pioneer in the science of reflow.

Transcript


Phil

And welcome to Board Talk with Jim Hall and Phil Zarrow, the Assembly Brothers of ITM Consulting. We are here to impart on you advice regarding electronic assembly, processes, materials, equipment, questions, answers

Today our question comes from S.M. IPC 709SC 6.4.2 discusses the maximum top-side board temperature for BGAs to be 150 degrees C during a tin-lead wave solder. Does anyone know how this temperature was determined? Are there supporting research papers or other IPC standards with more information? In the figure 6-25 there is a peak temperature listed for the fine pitch components over 160 C. Is there another standard that goes into this in more detail?

Jim

Well, we are talking about IPC specs, Phil. Perhaps you should describe the actual process by which IPC specifications are determined.

Phil

Okay, well they are done by committee. You have an organized consensus and they attempt to speak in things generically. I know there are people out there, among our readers, who can recite IPC specs number by number. That is good, we are happy for them. But the fact is that these things tend to be generic, generally good advice, a good starting point. Setting the committee aside there Jim, let’s go into what the application temperature is and what is going on here Jim?

Jim

With surface mount parts reflowed on a top-side of a board going through wave soldering, the one thing you don’t want to do is re-reflow those joints. It is always going to be below the melting temperature, in this case tin-lead 183. You also don’t want to partially melt them, where you might melt some of the joint and not the other. That is really bad.

That’s why both of these things, 150 and 160 that are quoted here by S.M. are well below the melting temperature. Why BGAs would be lower, 150 vs 160? My guess is because they are concerned about warpage of the BGA packages, deforming and damaging the solder joints. Tin-lead is not rated for 150 degrees surface temperature. When you take a tin-lead joint up to 150 degrees it starts to soften. It is still solid, but it has softened and it doesn’t have as much structural strength as when it is at 120.

My guess is that their concern is that because of the warpage with BGAs they don’t want to warp it too much and they don’t want to damage that solder joint from the stresses imposed by a warping package. Keeping the package temperature low and solder temperature low minimizes that possibility. That might not be so significant with another package.

I don’t know what is in figure 6.5 but say it is a fine-pitch gull wing package. You don’t have as big a warping issue putting stress on those joints as you do with a BGA. Again, I’m speculating but maybe that is why the BGA temperature is lower. To answer the final question, I don’t know that there are other standards that would go into this in more detail. I can’t tell you that.

Phil

How do you think that applies to BTCs, Jim? Now we are talking a lot less masking in that joint there. Warpage, plastic parts.

Jim

Phil, my general impression, I think it is possible but most BTCs are really small and warpage has not been indicated as that big a problem as it is with BGAs. But I can’t say that with 100 percent certainty.

I am going to put in a plug for the comments. All of you who hear this or read this are free to send a comment to Circuitnet and they are happy to print them. Therefore, if you are interested in this question and you are hearing it for the first time, wait a week or two and then go back and go into the archives and look up this session. See if people have commented on it. There are people out here who have more experience than Phil and I do and might be smarter and give you a better answer.

Phil

I think we answered S.M.’s question. Speaking of warpage and warped people, this is Phil and Jim of Board Talk advising you as you go forward, whether you are going to a pre-heat, wave solder, reflow, don’t solder like my brother.

Jim

And don’t solder like my brother.



Comments

Disclaimer: I'm a design EE, not a manufacturing guy but as far as committee recommendations, remember the classical definition of a committee: "A life form with six or more stomachs and no brain." The one thing I can say about standards (recommended or required) is that they evolve. I defer to my CM for process questions as they are the experts with their equipment and processes. Shipping things world-wide, all of our boards have to be RoHS so tin-lead isn't a process we allow any more, anyway.
Alan Ritter, MtRitter.com, LLC

Submit A Comment


Comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name


Your Company
Your E-mail


Your Country
Your Comments



Board Talk
Component Moisture Question?
5 vs 8-Zone Ovens
How To Verify Cleanliness After Rework and Prior to Re-coating?
BGA Components and Coplanarity
Demise of the Plated-Through Hole?
What is Solder Paste Working Life on a Stencil?
Simple Test for Flux Penetration
Step Stencil Setup
MORE BOARD TALK
Ask the Experts
Double sided SMT
Is lead contamination during cleaning of PB-free stencils possible?
BGA re-balling process
Using Solder Paste Beyond the Expiration Date
Conformal Coating Recommendation
Matte Black Solder Mask Defects
Oxidation of Solder Balls During Secondary Reflow
Rise of Bismuth Levels in our Solder Pots
MORE ASK THE EXPERTS