Electronics Assembly Knowledge, Vision & Wisdom
Hand Soldering Reliability
Hand Soldering Reliability
Can you comment on potential differences in reliability for SMT machine placement followed by reflow soldering vs. hand placement followed by hand soldering in surface mount? The Assembly Brothers, Jim Hall and Phil Zarrow, address this question.
Board Talk
Board Talk is presented by ITM Consulting

Phil Zarrow
Phil Zarrow, ITM Consulting
With over 35 years experience in PCB assembly, Phil is one of the leading experts in SMT process failure analysis. He has vast experience in SMT equipment, materials and processes.


Jim Hall
Jim Hall, ITM Consulting
A Lean Six-Sigma Master Blackbelt, Jim has a wealth of knowledge in soldering, thermal technology, equipment and process basics. He is a pioneer in the science of reflow.

ITM Consulting
* EMS Qualification, Evaluation and Selection
* SMT Process Consulting and Troubleshooting
* SMT Process Development and Set-up
* SMT Process Audits
* Lead-free Process Readiness Audits
* SMT Process Optimization
* On-Site Workshops
Submit A Comment
Comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name


Your Company


Your E-mail


Your Country


Your Comment



Transcript

Phil

And welcome to Board Talk, the Assembly Brothers, pick and place, who also go by ITM Consulting. Today we are trying to solve your process problems at ITM headquarters. We have a question from P.K. today.

P.K. says on occasion we have had to place a skip in our SMT placement machine due to unavailability of a surface mount component. The intention is to build the circuit card assembly using pick and place then and solder the missing components when available, except that there are times when you have to rework a job to replace the components but these should be kept to a minimum.

Can you comment on potential differences in reliability for SMT machine placement followed by reflow soldering vs. hand placement followed by hand soldering in surface mount?

Jim

The basic thing is an automated process you are as good as your machines. In a hand process you are as good as your operators. Now operators can be very good. You assume they are properly trained. You should be able to get as good solder joints and accurate placement as the automated process. In fact, I could argue that you should be able to get better soldering because with hand soldering you can custom adjust the process to each specific joint.

When you go through a reflow oven, all of the joints on a component and on a board see the same time temperature profile. With hand soldering you can adjust the exact amount of time you have to get the perfect wetting and so forth.

Assuming that your operators are trained and disciplined, you should be able to get good mechanical solder. The problem from a reliability standpoint is chemical and has to do with flux residues. If you are cleaning, you must clean the entire assembly, the whole board.

Localized cleaning does not work, it tends to move residues and bad chemicals under your adjacent components and cause long term reliability issues. If you are using a no-clean process you have to make sure that all of the no-clean fluxes on there were completely heated such that they are fully deactivated.

Phil

One of the other things is to not necessitate the need for cleaning in this case cosmetics, is to use as little flux as possible. Again, as Jim emphasized, not only in positioning the component but in the soldering.

Have a very well-trained operator doing this to minimize the amount of flux so there is not a lot of residue left over, assuming you are using no clean. Otherwise, if you are going to clean it great go for it.

Jim

No flux bottles. They should not be allowed on your floor. The proper way when hand soldering with no-clean is to use cord wire solder so that all of the flux is in the solder wire. It only comes out when the solder melts so therefore you have the best chance that all of that flux will be properly heated and therefore deactivated leaving a safe residue on the board.

If you have to add a little more flux, which we hate to even allow, use a flux pen that will just apply where it is touched. Once you start dripping liquid flux on a board that flux is inevitably going to run away, get under something and more importantly not be heated completely and therefore not deactivated, leaving active flux chemistry on the board that can affect the long-term reliability of your product.

Phil

As Jim also said, right now in the industry as we speak there is no such thing as selective cleaning. Select soldering yes, but selective cleaning no. The other thing is never clean up something strictly for cosmetics. This is the classic example of doing more harm than good.

Well, I hope we answered P.K.'s question here and other people too. I am sure we will hear comments on this. In the meantime, whether you are going to put it through a reflow machine, or hand soldering, or laser soldering induction whatever method you use, don't solder like my brother.

Jim

And don't solder like my brother.



Comments
No comments have been submitted to date.
Free Newsletter Subscription
Every issue of the Circuit Insight email newsletter will bring you the latest information on the issues affecting you and your company.

Insert Your Email Address

Directory Search


Program Search
Related Programs
bullet Why is Solder Dross Sticking to Our PCBAs?
bullet Will Nitrogen Reduce Wave Solder Defects?
bullet Surface Treatment Enabling Low Temperature Soldering to Aluminum
bullet Effect of Area Shape and Area Ratio on Solder Paste Printing Performance
bullet Alloy Composition and Aging on the Survivability of Lead-Free Solders
bullet Selective Soldering Design for Reliability Using SIR Test Method
bullet Rheology and Wetting Characterizations of Flux and Solder Paste
bullet Low Melting Temperature Interconnect Thermal Cycling Performance
bullet Converting Cable Assembly to Lead Free Solder
bullet What Causes Solder Balls During Hand Soldering?
More Related Programs