Fill the Void II: An Investigation into Methods of Reducing Voiding
Final Finish Specifications Review
DFX on High Density Assemblies
Challenges on ENEPIG Finished PCBs
Testing PCBs for Creep Corrosion
Screening of Lower Melting Point Pb-Free Alloys
Hand Printing using Nanocoated and other High End Stencil Materials
Board Processes and Effects on Fine Copper Barrel Cracks
Latest Industry News
Foxconn Says China Can No Longer Be 'The World's Factory'
Microsoft's new phone is ... $1,400? Why?
Hon Hai says Q2 results satisfactory
China Launches Beidou, Its Own Version of GPS
Do Engineers Live Longer? A Look at Occupational Factors' Effect on Longevity
The iPhone is still breaking sales records during the pandemic
How to Work from Home Successfully
Smartphone shipments in China plunge 35% in July

Improving properties of a Lead-free Solder Alloy with Doping of Copper

Improving properties of a Lead-free Solder Alloy with Doping of Copper
This paper reviews 3 lead-free solder alloys to assess the mechanical and thermal cycle properties by implementing drop tests and thermal cycle tests.
Materials Tech


Authored By:

Takehiro Wada, Seiji Tsuchiya, Kimiaki Mori, Takeshi Shirai
Koki Company Ltd., Japan

Shantanu Joshi, Roberto Garcia
Koki Solder America Inc., USA


For a demanding automotive electronics assembly, a highly thermal fatigue resistant solder alloy is required, which makes the lead-free Sn-Ag-Cu type solder alloy unusable. Sn-Ag-Bi-In solder alloy is considered as a high reliability solder alloy due to significant improvement in thermal fatigue resistance as compared to a standard Sn-Ag-Cu alloy. The alloy has not only good thermal fatigue properties but it also has superior ductility and tensile strength by appropriate addition of In; however, initial results indicated a sub-par performance in joint reliability when it is soldered on a printed circuit board (PCB) with Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold (ENIG) surface finish.

Numerous experiments were performed to find out appropriate alloying element which would help improve the performance on ENIG PCBs. Sn-Ag-Bi-In solder alloys with and without Cu additions were prepared and then tests were carried out to see the performance in a thermal fatigue test and a drop resistance investigate the impact of Cu addition towards the improvement of joint reliability on ENIG finish PCB. Also, the mechanism of such improvement is documented.


Three different kinds of lead-free solder alloys, SA1 as Sn-Ag-Cu type, SA2 as Sn-Ag-Bi-In type and SA3 as Sn-Ag-Bi-In-Cu type, were tested to assess the mechanical and thermal cycle properties by implementing board level drop test and thermal cycle tests. The test results combined with the cross-section observation revealed following the characteristics.

According to the solder joint strength and monitoring of the electrical resistance, thermal cycle properties of the solder joints on Cu-OSP board finish were evaluated as SA1
For the drop shock resistance test of SA2 and SA3 soldered on ENIG board finish, SA3 had higher mechanical drop test resistance than SA2.

Owing to the Cu addition in SA3, even if it is soldered on ENIG board finish, the growth of the intermetallic compound layer at the joint interface can be inhibited. The copper addition in the alloy also helps to inhibit the phosphorus

Initially Published in the IPC Proceedings


No comments have been submitted to date.

Submit A Comment

Comments are reviewed prior to posting. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name

Your Company
Your E-mail

Your Country
Your Comments

Board Talk
Cleaning Reballed BGA Components
We Bake, But Still Have Delamination, Why?
Reflow For Rigid Flex
Solder Paste Volume for BGA Rework
Problems With Starved "J" Lead Joints
Delay Before Cleaning Partial Assemblies
Can a CTE Mismatch Cause Reliability Problems?
Solder Paste Transfer Efficiency - What/Why
Ask the Experts
Soldering Components with Silver Pads
Environment Impact on Assembly, Printing and Reflow
Solder Balling Prediction Formula
Old Components and Blow Holes
Estimating Failure Rate During Rework
Coating to stop tin whisker growth?
Cleaning an assembled board with IPA
Remove and replace a 240 pin connector