Electronics Assembly Knowledge, Vision & Wisdom
The Case of the Falling Floor
The Case of the Falling Floor
The line was running when suddenly there was a loud thud. The floor, supporting a vertical beam had given way. What happened?
Mysteries of Science

Dr. Gilleo
Mysteries of Science by Dr. Ken Gilleo
Dr. Gilleo is a chemist, inventor and general problem solver. Ken has been tracking industrial forensics and collecting case histories for decades. These cases are taken from the vast world of industry and commercial enterprise.

Check out Dr. Gilleo's eBook, 100 Mysteries Solved by Science. We hope you enjoy these case histories. You need not be an engineer or scientist to understand the problems and appreciate the solutions.
The Northern Engraving metal finishing plant had every kind of metal finishing and decorating process. There were 100 big presses for cutting, punching, and shaping metal. There were also many wet processes, including metal etching and cleaning.

One morning the etching line was running when suddenly, there was a loud thud and the entire building shook. One worker pointed to the ceiling, upon closer inspection it became clear that part of the ceiling had dropped by at least a foot. The ceiling was sagging, but still supported by its steel structure and I-beams.

The floor, supporting a main vertical I-beam, had given way. The plant was on very solid ground and the thick concrete floor rested on a well-settled gravel bed.

What caused the floor to give way in this particular area of the factory?

Here's the rest of the story

Could the footing possibly have been bad? Maybe the concrete was bad? There was no obvious answer.

The ceiling was supported so that the area around the column could be excavated. As the digging proceeded, they exposed a black plastic pipe that ran under the floor. The layout plan showed that it was the waste acid pipe that went to the waste water treatment plant.

A joint was leaking into the surrounding concrete. The leak contained hydrofluoric acid used to etch glass and stone. The acid partially dissolved the floor and footing. The process may have taken quite awhile.

But ultimately the floor degraded enough to cause the problem.
Submit A Comment

Comments are reviewed prior to posting. Please avoid discussion of pricing or recommendations for specific products. You must include your full name to have your comments posted. We will not post your email address.

Your Name






Please type the number displayed into the box. If you receive an error, you may need to refresh the page and resubmit the information.

Related Programs
bullet The Disappearing Ink
bullet Fireworks on the Plating Line
bullet Light Without Light Bulbs
bullet Why Ford Asked for Lower Quality
bullet Trapped in the Vacuum Chamber
bullet The Day They Shut Down Intel
bullet The Frustrating Filter Fix
bullet The Case of the Falling Floor
bullet Wasp Vs. Spider
bullet Dead Phone and the Mysterious Dialer
More Related Programs